Google  


Tuesday, 30 September 2008

An Aztec Gem

Vanbrugh Hill

Here's a place you either love or hate. I'm not talking about what goes on inside, but the building itself. Where it stands now, it looks a bit incongruous as its friend, the monster that was Greenwich District Hospital, has now gone and it sits between Victorian villas and a giant hole, but it was once, not so very long ago, part of a 1970s vision.
Admittedly it wasn't a very good vision. I only know one person that mourns the architecture of that dead hospital, with its streaked grey concrete walls, forbidding brutalist walls and yellow-stained chimney. It certainly isn't me. For me that hospital, however handy practically, had absolutely nothing going for it aesthetically.
But this little building...
This building I like. Yes, it's seen better days - I'm sure when its architect drew it's "artist's impression" for the first time, it had Ancient Babylonian window boxes with cascading flowers from every level, rather than a couple of overgrown pot plants and some dead ivy, and the entrance hall is decidedly shabby. The nasty carpet tiles inside and solid concrete stairs drag it down, but just look at that exterior.
I seriously doubt the same architect who created the monstrosity next door designed this, though curiously, it's been nigh-on impossible for me to find anything out about either of the two buildings. It's as though both places have been or are to be expunged from the popular memory - as though that 30-odd years never happened. I've found NO records so far at all.
I love this building because there is something of the Aztec about it. That great stepped pyramid shape, the way it delves below street level - hell - even that service-room on top looks like some kind of ancient altar.
I'm sad that this building, I am told, is for the chop. This is one modern building I'd like to keep. Instead of pulling it down, I'd like to celebrate it. Redecorate inside; reinstate those Babylonian window boxes. Spend the cash saved on pulling it down and rebuilding on extra health services or frivolous touches. How about a reclining figure of Chris Roberts at the temple entrance, like those Mexican figures...
There are few modern buildings around Greenwich that have real architectural merit. Certainly, for me, the hospital didn't, and I'd be only too pleased to see the nasty complex in West Greenwich that houses Somerfield levelled. But I'm not one for throwing the baby out with the bathwater. This one, this one, I believe, has earned its place...

Labels: ,

9 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Dear Phantom

I agree that the old monster hospital had to go - perhaps people cheered when the ex-workhouse/hospital it replaced went, too many memories for that generation.

But if this building got the treatment that the Brunswick Centre in Bloomsbury has had it could be a gem. In the 80s and 90s the Brunswick centre was a grey, concrete horror. Now, wearing full slap and boasting a Waitrose, it's a very desirable place.

Maggie May

30 September 2008 09:13  
Blogger Benedict said...

Hmm thats a tricky one. I am just never sure about this building, it could do with a revamp and some planting I agree. Whether a new build would be better I just dont know , looking at the shocking and uninspired standard locally.
I think a Chris Roberts statue is a great idea perhaps a pair of "Chris's" 15 foot tall , stood up with his arms raised aloft holding big wads of cash?
A very different building I agree and I think that must be a good thing

30 September 2008 09:56  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Dear Phantom
This building was part of the old hospital and was a day medical centre. As far as I am aware this building was designed by the Architects Department of the Goverments Property Service Agency, now defunct. They were responsible for the design of all the goverment building during the 60s and 70s.
Although I know some of the architects who worked in the Southwark office of this department in those days I do not know who the project architect was. I have heard that it was Pierre La Gueste but I cannot confirm that. If anyone else knows it would be interesting to find out as I do agree that it is a very interesting building.

30 September 2008 10:01  
Anonymous Marcie said...

I have always understood that there was some structural problems - anyone know if that is so

30 September 2008 10:12  
Blogger NicksPhotos said...

I wouldn't be suprised if it does have structural problems, a lot of the concrete used for building back in the 60's was terrible quality and has a very short lifespan.

30 September 2008 10:26  
Anonymous donovan said...

I went round the Brunswick Centre on Open House weekend, which was fascinating - the flats are tiny and badly organized (it was basically shoeboxed into being same-size council flats, when it was originally intended as mixed-use private housing), but you have to admire the noble vision of the architects in the first place. On the other hand, despite the makeover, according to one of the residents, there's a real problem with damp...

30 September 2008 12:11  
Anonymous Oxide said...

This was, I believe, the Vanbrugh Hill Health center. Was our local family GP for many years when I was a kid before I grew up and moved slightly further afield.

Was a very good one at that, and they used to have an awesome fish tank. Wow, this has brought back some amazing memories that I had completely forgotten. Thankyou for posting this!

I was born in Greenwich Hospital, so even though it was an eyesore, I was sad to see it go.

PS. I was born in 1976, for those curious of the timescales! :)

01 October 2008 21:18  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Oxide, It still is a GP's office! I live about 3 seconds from it and everyone who works there is lovely. I can't believe they're pulling it down. It's already miles to the nearest hospital.

p.s they got rid of the fish task ages ago :(

02 October 2008 15:07  
Blogger methers said...

It certainly still is a health centre. And it will be moving into the new Heart of East Greenwich site along with another doctor's surgery. East Greenwich will have lots of doctors and health services, although other parts of the borough may lose out.

Found an interesting comment piece about the HoEG site here.

03 October 2008 16:21  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home